Android OS vs. Chrome OS


Google’s IO keynote is over. One day was dedicated to Chrome OS, another to Android OS — one day for each of Googles operating systems. Here’s what thay said about the next Android OS, Ice Cream Sandwich:

Our goal with Ice Cream Sandwich is to deliver one operating system that works everywhere, regardless of device. Ice Cream Sandwich will bring everything you love about Honeycomb on your tablet to your phone, including the holographic user interface, more multitasking, the new launcher and richer widgets.

So naturally, people are asking: if the goal is one OS for all devices, why does Chrome OS exist?

Continue reading

Android Ice Cream Sandwich is for phones and tablets

Eric Schmidt:

Today I’ll use the commonly used names. We have OS called gingerbread for phones, we have an OS being previewed now for tablets called Honeycomb. The two of them… you can imagine the follow up will start with an I, be named after dessert, and will combine these two.

Nailed it:

It’s a good bet the next version after those two is called “sandwich” for a good reason. I bet it’s because the goal of ice cream sandwich is to unify the base again, so phones and tablets run the same system.

Android 3.0 SDK preview reveals flat UI goodness

Google has released a preview for the Android 3 SDK, and it’s choc-full of UI goodness, including:


What’s so special about Android mail? Well it’s one of the plain apps, an app that is likely to be used the most on Android devices, and it’s got to be designed to just work, and from that perspective, this is one gorgeous piece of UI design. It’s deliciously almost flat, a design trend I expect to see explode like Apples noisy backgrounds. It’s got very few lines, and it’s got a delicious color palette. Dark blacks contrasting gray and white with a splash of accent color — Matias Duarte clearly gets contrast. It’ll look gorgeous on an OLED screen.

Which brings me to the System Bar — that line at the bottom which holds soft buttons for back, home and multitask, the notification bar, a clock, and battery info.

Wait, always present?

According to the SDK preview, yes.

But isn’t that a waste of precious pixels?

Depends on your point of view. The thing doesn’t use more than 48 pixels, and so it’s probably not a coincidence that these screenshots betray a device that’s 1280×800 px in resolution. That’s HD (1280×720) + 80 pixels. So this particular Android device will be able to play an HD video that’s almost perfectly vertically centered, while still permanently having a system bar present. Combine that with an OLED screen which uses the least power displaying the color black, and I approve.

Notes on Androids new Honeycomb UI

It’s CES time, which means a plethora of new slightly improved gadgets to hold us over until the next time we get slightly improved gadgets. For fans of Android and fans of UI design, Google dropped a bundle of joy in this video introduction to Android 3.0 “Honeycomb”. Here are screencaps and anecdotal commantary.


This must be Matias Duarte’s art style. Or perhaps the movie Tron Legacy designed the new Android?


No matter, I loved Tron Legacy (please go watch it so I can get a sequel!), I’ll learn to love this as well.


Nice lock screen. It’s still “something you drag from A to B”, but it’s probably not something Apple’s patented this time. Also, there’s a good chance this won’t unlock in your pocket (if you could fit a 10 inch tablet in your pocket, that is). That font though… It’s very 1993. The wallpaper is very 2001 though, which is actually not bad, just very techno.


New homescreen still shows select app shortcuts and widgets. So that’s classic Android with a new coat of paint and a nice new ubiquitous app launcher button (so you can launch a new app without going to the homescreen first).

The three buttons in the bottom left reveal potential awesomeness. We’ve been told (at one point) that Android tablets won’t have any facing physical buttons — no permanent context buttons — which in itself is a step forward. But these buttons, to me, look like “back”, “home” and “switch between apps”. Which, if true, spells the not-soon-enough death of the infamous “menu” button. Why is this good? It means that lazy Android app authors can no longer hide settings and help links in a mystery-meat hidden context menu. If they want their apps to be tablet compatible, that is.


Hey, that almost looks like Google Chrome, doesn’t it? Does that mean improved speed, standards support, bookmark sync, tabs and extensions? Oh my. I can see myself wanting one of these tablets now.

Overall, this looks really nice. Some of it is a bit off, but the sharp diagonals and mostly flat colors aesthetic seems to land in a good place between the delicous but spartan Windows Phone 7 UI and the overly textured and glossy iOS UI. It’s got some growing to do, but this a good place to grow from. The best thing: this UI feels like a serious jab at skin vendors like HTC and Motorola. People are going to want this UI, not “Sense” or “Blur”.

Android MIUI Mini-Review

MIUI is a japanese chinese (apologies, ed.) homebrew version of Googles Android operating system. It is installable via strange super-user voodoo, a process which is not for the faint of heart. I’ve talked about it before, but in a fit of boredom, I installed it. Here’s a mini-review.


The first thing you’ll notice in MIUI is that it’s replaced the default Droid Sans font with Helvetica, system-wide. From then on, it’s clear that Apples iOS has been the main inspiration for this Android custom ROM. This not only goes for the font, but it goes for the settings design, the semi-transparent statusbar and even to concepts such as the lack of an app-drawer, forcing all apps onto the homescreens. This last concept makes a lot of sense, and in the MIUI implementation, you get the added abillity to sort freely where your icons are placed — not just their order. That, and widgets and other Android niceties, of course.

miui_apps miui_folders2 miui_settings

In many ways, MIUI is tasteful. The lockscreen, while suffering from the same “too easy to unlock” stupidity as the HTC Sense lockscreen, is very pretty, and the stack of default wallpapers (even this stack is inspired by iOS) is gorgeous.


I’ve previously argued that building an entire Android distribution, just to be redesign the skin a little bit, is a bad idea. That said, MIUI does utilize the extra responsibility to do some neat tricks, such as the widget organizer as well as the statusbar tray power control.

miui_tray miui_widgets

In the end, however, MIUI does suffer from fragmentation-itis, and so you can expect instability to be inherent. Which once again illustrates the really basic concept: building an entire operating system is hard and difficult work. Forking a path in the road simply to be able to change the skin and add a few features, I find, is a waste of time; time better spent building the individual features and themes into Android Market apps.


Gmail Creator Paul Buchheit: Chrome OS Will Perish Or “Merge” With Android

Gmail Creator Paul Buchheit:

Prediction: ChromeOS will be killed next year (or “merged” with Android)

People don’t get it — I didn’t at first. Chrome OS is there to replace Windows XP for hospitals, municipalities, large corporations, clothing shops for inventory management, gyms, etc. Anywhere browser-based apps only are used, Chrome OS is going to be huge.

Sure, we’ll see Chrome on Android, but it’s becoming increasingly clear to me that Chrome OS is to Chrome what XBMC Live is to XBMC. It’s Chrome plus a wafer thin client, for the markets that need just that. Which is a lot of markets.