Android MIUI Mini-Review

MIUI is a japanese chinese (apologies, ed.) homebrew version of Googles Android operating system. It is installable via strange super-user voodoo, a process which is not for the faint of heart. I’ve talked about it before, but in a fit of boredom, I installed it. Here’s a mini-review.

miui_home4

The first thing you’ll notice in MIUI is that it’s replaced the default Droid Sans font with Helvetica, system-wide. From then on, it’s clear that Apples iOS has been the main inspiration for this Android custom ROM. This not only goes for the font, but it goes for the settings design, the semi-transparent statusbar and even to concepts such as the lack of an app-drawer, forcing all apps onto the homescreens. This last concept makes a lot of sense, and in the MIUI implementation, you get the added abillity to sort freely where your icons are placed — not just their order. That, and widgets and other Android niceties, of course.

miui_apps miui_folders2 miui_settings

In many ways, MIUI is tasteful. The lockscreen, while suffering from the same “too easy to unlock” stupidity as the HTC Sense lockscreen, is very pretty, and the stack of default wallpapers (even this stack is inspired by iOS) is gorgeous.

miui_themes

I’ve previously argued that building an entire Android distribution, just to be redesign the skin a little bit, is a bad idea. That said, MIUI does utilize the extra responsibility to do some neat tricks, such as the widget organizer as well as the statusbar tray power control.

miui_tray miui_widgets

In the end, however, MIUI does suffer from fragmentation-itis, and so you can expect instability to be inherent. Which once again illustrates the really basic concept: building an entire operating system is hard and difficult work. Forking a path in the road simply to be able to change the skin and add a few features, I find, is a waste of time; time better spent building the individual features and themes into Android Market apps.

miui_crash

4 thoughts on “Android MIUI Mini-Review”

  1. Gavin says:

    MIUI is from homebrew version of China not Japan http://www.miui.com/thread-1687-1-1.html

    1. Joen says:

      Gavin,

      Oops. Edited and apologized.

  2. Rob Mientjes says:

    Two points. First of all, it’s Arial, not Helvetica. Second, I wonder what Dave Lanham thinks of that third theme (“Cartoon Mob”) — it hinges on his illustration work.

    But some of those icons are delicious! Phone and Phonebook are sexy.

    1. Joen says:

      Rob Mientjes,

      Wow, you have a keen eye.

      I’ll shoot an email to Dave about this.

Comments are closed.